This technique is an alternative to the gap-fill activity that often accompanies a song. At first the students have no idea what the symbols mean, but slowly you will hear gasps of delight as some students start to guess the words.
The students are firstly given a handout of the symbol sheet which represents the song, and after trying to decipher as much as they can they can, they then listen to the song and compare with their ideas. The full lyrics can be shown to the students before they listen a second time.
- The Final Countdown symbolsong
- Mr Blue Sky symbolsong
- You’ll never walk alone symbolsong
- Beautiful Sunday symbolsong
- White Christmas symbolsong
- Ben (Michael Jackson) symbolsong
- Don’t Stop symbolsong
- Que Sera Sera symbolsong
- California dreamin’ symbolsong
- Rocking All Over The World symbolsong
- Over the Rainbow symbolsong
- Zip A Dee Doo Dah symbolsong
- Raining in my Heart symbolsong
- Sing symbolsong
- Hello, Goodbye symbolsong
Why use songs in the classroom?
While there is no conclusive evidence of songs helping language learning I think most teachers would agree they probably do.
Indeed research shows Broca’s area of the brain is concerned with both language and music, and a symbiotic, and even syntactic, relationship has been suggested between language and songs.
Here is a recent piece of research which suggests that language may even be a form of music.
The use of authentic language in the classroom is a concept fraught with perplexities. For example, no-one can seem to agree the definition of authentic language. And whether authentic language is actually of any value in the classroom can also be argued. However it would seem logical to suggest authentic language be used from time to time. And what better source of authentic language than a song?
And there are other good reasons for using songs. Songs are fun. Songs add an extra dimension to the lesson, something of beauty, culture and emotion. Songs really hit the heart of society. Classic songs are embedded in the fabric of culture, and familiarity with these songs will enable students to further integrate into the English-speaking world. And on top of all this, the rhythm of songs surely helps the rhythm of spoken English.
What kind of songs should be used?
There are songs and there are songs. Careful selection is needed, but it just a matter of common sense.
For example, for children simple, wholesome songs are obviously best. Lyrics should be clear (not drowned by a thumping beat), and topics such as love, beds, death, sorrow and cruelty should be avoided.
This cuts out a huge body of songs, but millions still remain. I start with ‘Hello, Goodbye‘, by The Beatles, for about 10 year-olds, followed by ‘Sing‘ by The Carpenters, and continue in this vein. Naturally, more mature students can handle more mature songs.
I prefer to use well-known, classic songs which students may well encounter in their daily life eg in a mall, on commercials, in movies. I feel an obscure song, even though it may be a really nice song, is far less useful.
What is a symbolsong?
I doubt if I am the first to use semiotics in song lyrics, representing some of the words with symbols, shorthand, and whatever comes to mind, and for this I have coined the term symbolsong.
Why use symbolsongs?
The sturdy gap-fill activity that is often used with song lyrics is tried and tested and works well.
A symbolsong is simply another technique to utilize songs in the classroom. Some songs seem to lend themselves better to gap-fill and others better to symbolsong, and some to both.
I find symbolsongs very stimulating for the students. My modus operandi is to give each student a copy of the symbolsong. At first the students have no idea what the symbols mean, but slowly there are gasps of delight as some students begin to guess the words. After trying to decipher as much as they can, the students then listen to the song and compare with their ideas. A second sheet with the full lyrics is then given for further comparison before the song is played a second time.
The bottom line is symbolsongs work.
Don’t symbolsongs take too long to prepare? Perhaps, but they can be used over and over.
Do the students get tired of symbolsongs? Not in my experience.
What about copyright issues?
I am not sure of all the implications here, but I believe if you use the songs and lyrics solely for educational purposes within the classroom, then I doubt whether anyone will come knocking at your door. You never know but somewhere down the line a student may even be inclined to purchase something by the artist or perhaps sing the song in a karaoke lounge (for which royalties are paid). In fact it could be said you are promoting the song and artist; would a record company object?
Songs rarely fit in with the other parts of my lesson.
Since a song is not written with a certain language item in mind the chance of it dovetailing perfectly with the particular linguistic aim of your lesson is remote. So why not treat a song as an independent part of the lesson, a stand-alone activity. Or better still, use the song as a springboard to the next part of the class eg reading and discussion of the life of Karen Carpenter.
In conclusion, the power of music is strong and memorable. Ignoring songs in the language classroom would seem to be an enormous missed opportunity.